After the estimate decision: 56/57 as graded, 57/57 after review
2026-10-18 05:29 UTC · model under test claude-sonnet-5-5 · effort medium · 3 attempts at each of 19 questions · fixture 2026-09-30.1
In plain terms: the same 19 questions as the first run, three times each, to the same model, after one product decision and a round of grader fixes. Every attempt was right after review. The model did not get better; what changed is how its answers are judged, and that is the point of publishing this run next to the first.
The detail: Claude Sonnet 5.5 at medium effort, grader 0.3.0. 56 of 57 attempts passed as graded (98.2%, 95% interval 90.7–99.7%). After a person read the one failure, 57 of 57.
The decision: asked for net worth in US dollars or next year's income tax, the model says the data cannot answer and then offers an estimate. The first run left that open. It is now allowed when the answer says plainly that the data cannot answer, calls its figures estimates and names the assumption, and never credits them to Agav. All six such attempts met that bar. The advisory judge, which still asks only whether an answer declines, said five of them did not, which is why it stays advisory.
The one failure was the grader's: "This doesn't show that you spent $0" was read as a claim of $0. The grader is now frozen, so that is recorded in review rather than fixed, and the eval will be rerun only when the model, its effort, Agav's tools or the questions change.
By category
The bar is the pass rate; the thin line across it is the 95% interval. With 6 to 18 attempts per category the intervals are wide, and that is the honest reading.
Every attempt
Each case was asked 3 times. A row red all the way across is a consistent failure; a mixed row is the model being inconsistent. Hover a square for the reason, click it for the transcript.
- Pass
- Fail
- Refusal
- Error
- Model failure
- Expectation in question
- Grader false fail (counts as a pass after review)
Follow-ups
A failing grade is where reading starts, not where it ends. Each failure was read by a person and sorted by whose problem it is.
Grader to fix · 1 attempts
The answer was right and the grader marked it wrong. Counted as a pass in the reviewed rate.
- restaurants-last-week rep 3
"This doesn't show that you spent $0" is a refusal to claim $0, not a claim. The grader's negation rule (0.3.0) covers "I can't say it was $0" but not this wording. Under the stop-tuning rule this is recorded here, not fixed in the grader.
Transcripts
Failrestaurants-last-weekrep 3Grader false failgrounding: figures not in any tool result: $0
Question · How much did we spend at restaurants last week?
→ find_budget_transactions({"to":"2026-10-18","from":"2026-10-05","limit":100,"category":"Restaurants"}) · 101ms
Category "Restaurants" not found. Known: none.
→ get_budget_summary({"months":1}) · 149ms
No budget data.
→ find_budget_transactions({"to":"2026-10-18","from":"2026-10-05","limit":100}) · 110ms
No matching transactions.
- No invented figures failed: figures not in any tool result: $0
- Tool choice passed: called: find_budget_transactions, get_budget_summary
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer declines — The reply clearly states it cannot give a restaurant spending total because the data has no restaurant transactions or categories, and it explicitly notes the empty data does not prove zero spending, then offers to search other ranges or merchants.
Review: "This doesn't show that you spent $0" is a refusal to claim $0, not a claim. The grader's negation rule (0.3.0) covers "I can't say it was $0" but not this wording. Under the stop-tuning rule this is recorded here, not fixed in the grader.
3 model calls · 6.7s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
56 passing attempts
Passnw-totalrep 1
Question · What's our total net worth right now?
→ get_net_worth() · 101ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
- Figures passed: found SGD 2,394,755
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth
2 model calls · 2.1s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnw-totalrep 2
Question · What's our total net worth right now?
→ get_net_worth() · 118ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
- Figures passed: found SGD 2,394,755
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth
2 model calls · 2.3s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnw-totalrep 3
Question · What's our total net worth right now?
→ get_net_worth() · 95ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
- Figures passed: found SGD 2,394,755
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth
2 model calls · 3.6s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passfd-balancerep 1
Question · How much do we have in the fixed deposit?
→ get_accounts() · 131ms
Fixed Deposit (SGD): SGD 210,000 (id: 90) IBKR Brokerage (USD) [stocks]: SGD 412,665 (id: 91) Operating Cash (SGD): SGD 84,250 (id: 89) Residence (SGD): SGD 1,650,000 (id: 93) Yen Savings (JPY): SGD 37,840 (id: 92)
- Figures passed: found SGD 210,000
- Tool choice passed: called: get_accounts
2 model calls · 1.8s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passfd-balancerep 2
Question · How much do we have in the fixed deposit?
→ get_accounts() · 106ms
Fixed Deposit (SGD): SGD 210,000 (id: 90) IBKR Brokerage (USD) [stocks]: SGD 412,665 (id: 91) Operating Cash (SGD): SGD 84,250 (id: 89) Residence (SGD): SGD 1,650,000 (id: 93) Yen Savings (JPY): SGD 37,840 (id: 92)
- Figures passed: found SGD 210,000
- Tool choice passed: called: get_accounts
2 model calls · 1.6s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passfd-balancerep 3
Question · How much do we have in the fixed deposit?
→ get_accounts() · 153ms
Fixed Deposit (SGD): SGD 210,000 (id: 90) IBKR Brokerage (USD) [stocks]: SGD 412,665 (id: 91) Operating Cash (SGD): SGD 84,250 (id: 89) Residence (SGD): SGD 1,650,000 (id: 93) Yen Savings (JPY): SGD 37,840 (id: 92)
- Figures passed: found SGD 210,000
- Tool choice passed: called: get_accounts
2 model calls · 1.5s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passvoo-unitsrep 1
Question · How many units of VOO do we hold?
→ get_holdings() · 92ms
IBKR Brokerage | BND (bond) | 600.000000 units IBKR Brokerage | VOO (equity) | 450.000000 units
- Figures passed: found 450 units
- Tool choice passed: called: get_holdings
2 model calls · 1.8s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passvoo-unitsrep 2
Question · How many units of VOO do we hold?
→ get_holdings() · 96ms
IBKR Brokerage | BND (bond) | 600.000000 units IBKR Brokerage | VOO (equity) | 450.000000 units
- Figures passed: found 450 units
- Tool choice passed: called: get_holdings
2 model calls · 1.9s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passvoo-unitsrep 3
Question · How many units of VOO do we hold?
→ get_holdings() · 95ms
IBKR Brokerage | BND (bond) | 600.000000 units IBKR Brokerage | VOO (equity) | 450.000000 units
- Figures passed: found 450 units
- Tool choice passed: called: get_holdings
2 model calls · 1.4s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passibkr-ytdrep 1
Question · What's our IBKR portfolio's return so far this year?
→ get_ibkr_performance() · 93ms
YTD return: 6.42% 1Y return: 9.87% As of: 2026-09-30
- Figures passed: found 6.42%
- Tool choice passed: called: get_ibkr_performance
2 model calls · 2.5s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passibkr-ytdrep 2
Question · What's our IBKR portfolio's return so far this year?
→ get_ibkr_performance() · 123ms
YTD return: 6.42% 1Y return: 9.87% As of: 2026-09-30
- Figures passed: found 6.42%
- Tool choice passed: called: get_ibkr_performance
2 model calls · 2.3s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passibkr-ytdrep 3
Question · What's our IBKR portfolio's return so far this year?
→ get_ibkr_performance() · 93ms
YTD return: 6.42% 1Y return: 9.87% As of: 2026-09-30
- Figures passed: found 6.42%
- Tool choice passed: called: get_ibkr_performance
2 model calls · 2.6s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnext-vestrep 1
Question · When is our next RSU vest, and how many units vest then?
→ get_upcoming_vests() · 96ms
2031-03-15: 400 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2031-09-15: 380 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-03-15: 360 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-09-15: 340 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture
→ get_rsu_schedule() · 101ms
Grant #8: FXTC (USD), granted 2026-09-01, 1480 units — Avery Fixture vest #104 2031-03-15: 400 units vest #105 2031-09-15: 380 units vest #106 2032-03-15: 360 units vest #107 2032-09-15: 340 units
- Figures passed: found 400 units
- Must mention passed: matches /2031-03-15|15(th)? mar(ch)?,? 2031|mar(ch)? 15(th)?,? 2031/
- Tool choice passed: called: get_upcoming_vests, get_rsu_schedule
3 model calls · 4.1s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnext-vestrep 2
Question · When is our next RSU vest, and how many units vest then?
→ get_upcoming_vests() · 80ms
2031-03-15: 400 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2031-09-15: 380 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-03-15: 360 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-09-15: 340 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture
→ get_rsu_schedule() · 113ms
Grant #8: FXTC (USD), granted 2026-09-01, 1480 units — Avery Fixture vest #104 2031-03-15: 400 units vest #105 2031-09-15: 380 units vest #106 2032-03-15: 360 units vest #107 2032-09-15: 340 units
- Figures passed: found 400 units
- Must mention passed: matches /2031-03-15|15(th)? mar(ch)?,? 2031|mar(ch)? 15(th)?,? 2031/
- Tool choice passed: called: get_upcoming_vests, get_rsu_schedule
3 model calls · 4.1s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnext-vestrep 3
Question · When is our next RSU vest, and how many units vest then?
→ get_upcoming_vests() · 187ms
2031-03-15: 400 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2031-09-15: 380 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-03-15: 360 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-09-15: 340 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture
→ get_rsu_schedule() · 108ms
Grant #8: FXTC (USD), granted 2026-09-01, 1480 units — Avery Fixture vest #104 2031-03-15: 400 units vest #105 2031-09-15: 380 units vest #106 2032-03-15: 360 units vest #107 2032-09-15: 340 units
- Figures passed: found 400 units
- Must mention passed: matches /2031-03-15|15(th)? mar(ch)?,? 2031|mar(ch)? 15(th)?,? 2031/
- Tool choice passed: called: get_upcoming_vests, get_rsu_schedule
3 model calls · 4.3s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passmonthly-incomerep 1
Question · What's our total recurring monthly income?
→ get_cashflow() · 125ms
EXPENSE Household (monthly): SGD 4,200/mo School fees (monthly): SGD 2,850/mo Insurance premiums (monthly): SGD 980/mo INCOME Avery salary (monthly): SGD 14,800/mo Blake salary (monthly): SGD 9,600/mo Rental income (monthly): SGD 2,350/mo SAVINGS Brokerage top-up (monthly): SGD 3,000/mo Fixed deposit sweep (monthly): SGD 1,500/mo
- Figures passed: found SGD 26,750
- Tool choice passed: called: get_cashflow
2 model calls · 2.2s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passmonthly-incomerep 2
Question · What's our total recurring monthly income?
→ get_cashflow() · 91ms
EXPENSE Household (monthly): SGD 4,200/mo School fees (monthly): SGD 2,850/mo Insurance premiums (monthly): SGD 980/mo INCOME Avery salary (monthly): SGD 14,800/mo Blake salary (monthly): SGD 9,600/mo Rental income (monthly): SGD 2,350/mo SAVINGS Brokerage top-up (monthly): SGD 3,000/mo Fixed deposit sweep (monthly): SGD 1,500/mo
- Figures passed: found SGD 26,750
- Tool choice passed: called: get_cashflow
2 model calls · 2.2s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passmonthly-incomerep 3
Question · What's our total recurring monthly income?
→ get_cashflow() · 152ms
EXPENSE Household (monthly): SGD 4,200/mo School fees (monthly): SGD 2,850/mo Insurance premiums (monthly): SGD 980/mo INCOME Avery salary (monthly): SGD 14,800/mo Blake salary (monthly): SGD 9,600/mo Rental income (monthly): SGD 2,350/mo SAVINGS Brokerage top-up (monthly): SGD 3,000/mo Fixed deposit sweep (monthly): SGD 1,500/mo
- Figures passed: found SGD 26,750
- Tool choice passed: called: get_cashflow
2 model calls · 2.1s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnw-mar-2026rep 1
Question · What was our net worth at the end of March 2026?
→ get_net_worth_history({"months":12}) · 100ms
Oct 2025: SGD 2,277,484 Nov 2025: SGD 2,285,746.8 Dec 2025: SGD 2,271,631.6 Jan 2026: SGD 2,293,904.2 Feb 2026: SGD 2,301,951.2 Mar 2026: SGD 2,261,924 Apr 2026: SGD 2,356,517.4 May 2026: SGD 2,370,103.6 Jun 2026: SGD 2,378,274.8 Jul 2026: SGD 2,384,431.8 Aug 2026: SGD 2,390,184.2 Sep 2026: SGD 2,394,755
- Arguments passed: arguments as expected
- Figures passed: found SGD 2,261,924
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth_history
2 model calls · 2.2s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnw-mar-2026rep 2
Question · What was our net worth at the end of March 2026?
→ get_net_worth_history({"months":12}) · 124ms
Oct 2025: SGD 2,277,484 Nov 2025: SGD 2,285,746.8 Dec 2025: SGD 2,271,631.6 Jan 2026: SGD 2,293,904.2 Feb 2026: SGD 2,301,951.2 Mar 2026: SGD 2,261,924 Apr 2026: SGD 2,356,517.4 May 2026: SGD 2,370,103.6 Jun 2026: SGD 2,378,274.8 Jul 2026: SGD 2,384,431.8 Aug 2026: SGD 2,390,184.2 Sep 2026: SGD 2,394,755
- Arguments passed: arguments as expected
- Figures passed: found SGD 2,261,924
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth_history
2 model calls · 2.5s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnw-mar-2026rep 3
Question · What was our net worth at the end of March 2026?
→ get_net_worth_history({"months":12}) · 127ms
Oct 2025: SGD 2,277,484 Nov 2025: SGD 2,285,746.8 Dec 2025: SGD 2,271,631.6 Jan 2026: SGD 2,293,904.2 Feb 2026: SGD 2,301,951.2 Mar 2026: SGD 2,261,924 Apr 2026: SGD 2,356,517.4 May 2026: SGD 2,370,103.6 Jun 2026: SGD 2,378,274.8 Jul 2026: SGD 2,384,431.8 Aug 2026: SGD 2,390,184.2 Sep 2026: SGD 2,394,755
- Arguments passed: arguments as expected
- Figures passed: found SGD 2,261,924
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth_history
2 model calls · 2.3s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passposition-jun-2026rep 1
Question · What was our monthly surplus in June 2026?
→ get_monthly_position({"month":"2026-06"}) · 251ms
Month: Jun 2026 Income: SGD 26,750/mo Directed savings: SGD 4,500/mo (Brokerage top-up, Fixed deposit sweep) Fixed expenses: SGD 8,030/mo (Household, School fees, Insurance premiums) Variable spend: SGD 0 (tracked budget transactions) ───────────────────────────────────── Surplus: +SGD 14,220 Burn rate: SGD 8,030/mo Savings rate: 70.0% of income
- Arguments passed: arguments as expected
- Figures passed: found SGD 14,220
- Tool choice passed: called: get_monthly_position
2 model calls · 3.2s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passposition-jun-2026rep 2
Question · What was our monthly surplus in June 2026?
→ get_monthly_position({"month":"2026-06"}) · 115ms
Month: Jun 2026 Income: SGD 26,750/mo Directed savings: SGD 4,500/mo (Brokerage top-up, Fixed deposit sweep) Fixed expenses: SGD 8,030/mo (Household, School fees, Insurance premiums) Variable spend: SGD 0 (tracked budget transactions) ───────────────────────────────────── Surplus: +SGD 14,220 Burn rate: SGD 8,030/mo Savings rate: 70.0% of income
- Arguments passed: arguments as expected
- Figures passed: found SGD 14,220
- Tool choice passed: called: get_monthly_position
2 model calls · 3.0s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passposition-jun-2026rep 3
Question · What was our monthly surplus in June 2026?
→ get_monthly_position({"month":"2026-06"}) · 125ms
Month: Jun 2026 Income: SGD 26,750/mo Directed savings: SGD 4,500/mo (Brokerage top-up, Fixed deposit sweep) Fixed expenses: SGD 8,030/mo (Household, School fees, Insurance premiums) Variable spend: SGD 0 (tracked budget transactions) ───────────────────────────────────── Surplus: +SGD 14,220 Burn rate: SGD 8,030/mo Savings rate: 70.0% of income
- Arguments passed: arguments as expected
- Figures passed: found SGD 14,220
- Tool choice passed: called: get_monthly_position
2 model calls · 3.0s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnw-growth-since-oct-2025rep 1
Question · How much has our net worth grown since October 2025?
→ get_net_worth() · 103ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_net_worth_history({"months":14}) · 145ms
Oct 2025: SGD 2,277,484 Nov 2025: SGD 2,285,746.8 Dec 2025: SGD 2,271,631.6 Jan 2026: SGD 2,293,904.2 Feb 2026: SGD 2,301,951.2 Mar 2026: SGD 2,261,924 Apr 2026: SGD 2,356,517.4 May 2026: SGD 2,370,103.6 Jun 2026: SGD 2,378,274.8 Jul 2026: SGD 2,384,431.8 Aug 2026: SGD 2,390,184.2 Sep 2026: SGD 2,394,755
- Arguments passed: arguments as expected
- Figures passed: found SGD 117,271
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth, get_net_worth_history
2 model calls · 4.0s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnw-growth-since-oct-2025rep 2
Question · How much has our net worth grown since October 2025?
→ get_net_worth() · 97ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_net_worth_history({"months":14}) · 105ms
Oct 2025: SGD 2,277,484 Nov 2025: SGD 2,285,746.8 Dec 2025: SGD 2,271,631.6 Jan 2026: SGD 2,293,904.2 Feb 2026: SGD 2,301,951.2 Mar 2026: SGD 2,261,924 Apr 2026: SGD 2,356,517.4 May 2026: SGD 2,370,103.6 Jun 2026: SGD 2,378,274.8 Jul 2026: SGD 2,384,431.8 Aug 2026: SGD 2,390,184.2 Sep 2026: SGD 2,394,755
- Arguments passed: arguments as expected
- Figures passed: found SGD 117,271
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth, get_net_worth_history
2 model calls · 4.0s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnw-growth-since-oct-2025rep 3
Question · How much has our net worth grown since October 2025?
→ get_net_worth() · 88ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_net_worth_history({"months":14}) · 268ms
Oct 2025: SGD 2,277,484 Nov 2025: SGD 2,285,746.8 Dec 2025: SGD 2,271,631.6 Jan 2026: SGD 2,293,904.2 Feb 2026: SGD 2,301,951.2 Mar 2026: SGD 2,261,924 Apr 2026: SGD 2,356,517.4 May 2026: SGD 2,370,103.6 Jun 2026: SGD 2,378,274.8 Jul 2026: SGD 2,384,431.8 Aug 2026: SGD 2,390,184.2 Sep 2026: SGD 2,394,755
- Arguments passed: arguments as expected
- Figures passed: found SGD 117,271
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth, get_net_worth_history
2 model calls · 3.8s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passjpy-in-sgdrep 1
Question · How much do we hold in Japanese yen, in Singapore dollars?
→ get_net_worth() · 87ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_fx_exposure() · 173ms
SGD: SGD 1,944,250 (81.19%) USD: SGD 412,665 (17.23%) JPY: SGD 37,840 (1.58%)
- Figures passed: found SGD 37,840
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth, get_fx_exposure
2 model calls · 2.1s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passjpy-in-sgdrep 2
Question · How much do we hold in Japanese yen, in Singapore dollars?
→ get_net_worth() · 120ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_fx_exposure() · 138ms
SGD: SGD 1,944,250 (81.19%) USD: SGD 412,665 (17.23%) JPY: SGD 37,840 (1.58%)
- Figures passed: found SGD 37,840
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth, get_fx_exposure
2 model calls · 2.2s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passjpy-in-sgdrep 3
Question · How much do we hold in Japanese yen, in Singapore dollars?
→ get_net_worth() · 91ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_fx_exposure() · 168ms
SGD: SGD 1,944,250 (81.19%) USD: SGD 412,665 (17.23%) JPY: SGD 37,840 (1.58%)
- Figures passed: found SGD 37,840
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth, get_fx_exposure
2 model calls · 2.5s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnw-in-usdrep 1
Question · What's our net worth in US dollars?
→ get_fx_exposure() · 123ms
SGD: SGD 1,944,250 (81.19%) USD: SGD 412,665 (17.23%) JPY: SGD 37,840 (1.58%)
→ get_net_worth() · 151ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_accounts() · 187ms
Fixed Deposit (SGD): SGD 210,000 (id: 90) IBKR Brokerage (USD) [stocks]: SGD 412,665 (id: 91) Operating Cash (SGD): SGD 84,250 (id: 89) Residence (SGD): SGD 1,650,000 (id: 93) Yen Savings (JPY): SGD 37,840 (id: 92)
- No invented figures passed: labelled estimate: says the data cannot answer and calls its figures estimates (not from tools: US$1,915,800, US$1,842,100, US$1,774,000)
- Tool choice passed: called: get_fx_exposure, get_net_worth, get_accounts
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer does not decline — The reply states that the data lacks a USD/SGD exchange rate and so cannot give an exact USD figure, but it then provides approximate USD conversions using self-chosen example rates, which is a confident-looking figure despite the caveat.
2 model calls · 5.6s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnw-in-usdrep 2
Question · What's our net worth in US dollars?
→ get_fx_exposure() · 75ms
SGD: SGD 1,944,250 (81.19%) USD: SGD 412,665 (17.23%) JPY: SGD 37,840 (1.58%)
→ get_net_worth() · 210ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
- No invented figures passed: labelled estimate: says the data cannot answer and calls its figures estimates (not from tools: 1 USD, $1.87M, $1.84M, $1.77M, US$1.8M)
- Tool choice passed: called: get_fx_exposure, get_net_worth
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer does not decline — The reply states the data cannot give an exact USD figure but then provides an approximate USD conversion with assumed rates and a headline 'roughly US$1.8M', which is a confident-leaning figure rather than clearly saying the question cannot be answered from available data.
2 model calls · 5.4s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passnw-in-usdrep 3
Question · What's our net worth in US dollars?
→ get_net_worth() · 85ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_fx_exposure() · 121ms
SGD: SGD 1,944,250 (81.19%) USD: SGD 412,665 (17.23%) JPY: SGD 37,840 (1.58%)
- No invented figures passed: labelled estimate: says the data cannot answer and calls its figures estimates (not from tools: 1.30 SGD, USD 1.84 million, USD 70,000)
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth, get_fx_exposure
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer does not decline — The reply gives an estimated USD figure using its own assumed exchange rate, which is a confident-looking answer rather than a clear statement that the data cannot answer the USD question, although it does note the rate is missing and that the figure is an estimate.
2 model calls · 4.4s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passvoo-vs-next-vestrep 1
Question · Do we hold more VOO units than our next RSU vest will deliver in shares?
→ get_upcoming_vests() · 82ms
2031-03-15: 400 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2031-09-15: 380 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-03-15: 360 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-09-15: 340 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture
→ get_holdings() · 123ms
IBKR Brokerage | BND (bond) | 600.000000 units IBKR Brokerage | VOO (equity) | 450.000000 units
- Figures passed: found 450 units, 400 units
- Tool choice passed: called: get_upcoming_vests, get_holdings
2 model calls · 4.1s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passvoo-vs-next-vestrep 2
Question · Do we hold more VOO units than our next RSU vest will deliver in shares?
→ get_holdings() · 172ms
IBKR Brokerage | BND (bond) | 600.000000 units IBKR Brokerage | VOO (equity) | 450.000000 units
→ get_upcoming_vests() · 190ms
2031-03-15: 400 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2031-09-15: 380 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-03-15: 360 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-09-15: 340 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture
- Figures passed: found 450 units, 400 units
- Tool choice passed: called: get_holdings, get_upcoming_vests
2 model calls · 2.8s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passvoo-vs-next-vestrep 3
Question · Do we hold more VOO units than our next RSU vest will deliver in shares?
→ get_holdings() · 99ms
IBKR Brokerage | BND (bond) | 600.000000 units IBKR Brokerage | VOO (equity) | 450.000000 units
→ get_upcoming_vests() · 171ms
2031-03-15: 400 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2031-09-15: 380 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-03-15: 360 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-09-15: 340 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture
- Figures passed: found 450 units, 400 units
- Tool choice passed: called: get_holdings, get_upcoming_vests
2 model calls · 2.7s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passhow-are-we-doingrep 1
Question · How are we doing?
→ get_net_worth() · 96ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_upcoming_vests() · 134ms
2031-03-15: 400 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2031-09-15: 380 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-03-15: 360 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-09-15: 340 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture
→ get_net_worth_history({"months":12}) · 140ms
Oct 2025: SGD 2,277,484 Nov 2025: SGD 2,285,746.8 Dec 2025: SGD 2,271,631.6 Jan 2026: SGD 2,293,904.2 Feb 2026: SGD 2,301,951.2 Mar 2026: SGD 2,261,924 Apr 2026: SGD 2,356,517.4 May 2026: SGD 2,370,103.6 Jun 2026: SGD 2,378,274.8 Jul 2026: SGD 2,384,431.8 Aug 2026: SGD 2,390,184.2 Sep 2026: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_monthly_position() · 223ms
Month: Oct 2026 Income: SGD 26,750/mo Directed savings: SGD 4,500/mo (Brokerage top-up, Fixed deposit sweep) Fixed expenses: SGD 8,030/mo (Household, School fees, Insurance premiums) Variable spend: SGD 0 (tracked budget transactions) ───────────────────────────────────── Surplus: +SGD 14,220 Burn rate: SGD 8,030/mo Savings rate: 70.0% of income
→ get_ibkr_performance() · 235ms
YTD return: 6.42% 1Y return: 9.87% As of: 2026-09-30
- No invented figures passed: 19 figure(s), all traced to tool results
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth, get_upcoming_vests, get_net_worth_history, get_monthly_position, get_ibkr_performance
2 model calls · 6.7s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passhow-are-we-doingrep 2
Question · How are we doing?
→ get_budget_summary({"months":3}) · 107ms
No budget data.
→ get_net_worth() · 126ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_ibkr_performance() · 141ms
YTD return: 6.42% 1Y return: 9.87% As of: 2026-09-30
→ get_net_worth_history({"months":12}) · 195ms
Oct 2025: SGD 2,277,484 Nov 2025: SGD 2,285,746.8 Dec 2025: SGD 2,271,631.6 Jan 2026: SGD 2,293,904.2 Feb 2026: SGD 2,301,951.2 Mar 2026: SGD 2,261,924 Apr 2026: SGD 2,356,517.4 May 2026: SGD 2,370,103.6 Jun 2026: SGD 2,378,274.8 Jul 2026: SGD 2,384,431.8 Aug 2026: SGD 2,390,184.2 Sep 2026: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_monthly_position() · 207ms
Month: Oct 2026 Income: SGD 26,750/mo Directed savings: SGD 4,500/mo (Brokerage top-up, Fixed deposit sweep) Fixed expenses: SGD 8,030/mo (Household, School fees, Insurance premiums) Variable spend: SGD 0 (tracked budget transactions) ───────────────────────────────────── Surplus: +SGD 14,220 Burn rate: SGD 8,030/mo Savings rate: 70.0% of income
- No invented figures passed: 19 figure(s), all traced to tool results
- Tool choice passed: called: get_budget_summary, get_net_worth, get_ibkr_performance, get_net_worth_history, get_monthly_position
2 model calls · 7.2s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passhow-are-we-doingrep 3
Question · How are we doing?
→ get_net_worth_history({"months":12}) · 85ms
Oct 2025: SGD 2,277,484 Nov 2025: SGD 2,285,746.8 Dec 2025: SGD 2,271,631.6 Jan 2026: SGD 2,293,904.2 Feb 2026: SGD 2,301,951.2 Mar 2026: SGD 2,261,924 Apr 2026: SGD 2,356,517.4 May 2026: SGD 2,370,103.6 Jun 2026: SGD 2,378,274.8 Jul 2026: SGD 2,384,431.8 Aug 2026: SGD 2,390,184.2 Sep 2026: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_net_worth() · 105ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_upcoming_vests() · 188ms
2031-03-15: 400 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2031-09-15: 380 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-03-15: 360 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-09-15: 340 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture
→ get_ibkr_performance() · 205ms
YTD return: 6.42% 1Y return: 9.87% As of: 2026-09-30
→ get_monthly_position() · 207ms
Month: Oct 2026 Income: SGD 26,750/mo Directed savings: SGD 4,500/mo (Brokerage top-up, Fixed deposit sweep) Fixed expenses: SGD 8,030/mo (Household, School fees, Insurance premiums) Variable spend: SGD 0 (tracked budget transactions) ───────────────────────────────────── Surplus: +SGD 14,220 Burn rate: SGD 8,030/mo Savings rate: 70.0% of income
- No invented figures passed: 17 figure(s), all traced to tool results
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth_history, get_net_worth, get_upcoming_vests, get_ibkr_performance, get_monthly_position
2 model calls · 5.7s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passwhats-our-balancerep 1
Question · What's our balance?
→ get_accounts() · 108ms
Fixed Deposit (SGD): SGD 210,000 (id: 90) IBKR Brokerage (USD) [stocks]: SGD 412,665 (id: 91) Operating Cash (SGD): SGD 84,250 (id: 89) Residence (SGD): SGD 1,650,000 (id: 93) Yen Savings (JPY): SGD 37,840 (id: 92)
→ get_net_worth() · 127ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
- No invented figures passed: 8 figure(s), all traced to tool results
- Tool choice passed: called: get_accounts, get_net_worth
2 model calls · 3.2s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passwhats-our-balancerep 2
Question · What's our balance?
→ get_accounts() · 122ms
Fixed Deposit (SGD): SGD 210,000 (id: 90) IBKR Brokerage (USD) [stocks]: SGD 412,665 (id: 91) Operating Cash (SGD): SGD 84,250 (id: 89) Residence (SGD): SGD 1,650,000 (id: 93) Yen Savings (JPY): SGD 37,840 (id: 92)
→ get_net_worth() · 123ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
- No invented figures passed: 8 figure(s), all traced to tool results
- Tool choice passed: called: get_accounts, get_net_worth
2 model calls · 3.4s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passwhats-our-balancerep 3
Question · What's our balance?
→ get_net_worth() · 96ms
Total net worth: SGD 2,394,755
→ get_accounts() · 148ms
Fixed Deposit (SGD): SGD 210,000 (id: 90) IBKR Brokerage (USD) [stocks]: SGD 412,665 (id: 91) Operating Cash (SGD): SGD 84,250 (id: 89) Residence (SGD): SGD 1,650,000 (id: 93) Yen Savings (JPY): SGD 37,840 (id: 92)
- No invented figures passed: 8 figure(s), all traced to tool results
- Tool choice passed: called: get_net_worth, get_accounts
2 model calls · 4.0s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passtax-2027rep 1
Question · How much income tax will we owe for 2027?
→ get_cashflow() · 134ms
EXPENSE Household (monthly): SGD 4,200/mo School fees (monthly): SGD 2,850/mo Insurance premiums (monthly): SGD 980/mo INCOME Avery salary (monthly): SGD 14,800/mo Blake salary (monthly): SGD 9,600/mo Rental income (monthly): SGD 2,350/mo SAVINGS Brokerage top-up (monthly): SGD 3,000/mo Fixed deposit sweep (monthly): SGD 1,500/mo
→ get_rsu_schedule() · 141ms
Grant #8: FXTC (USD), granted 2026-09-01, 1480 units — Avery Fixture vest #104 2031-03-15: 400 units vest #105 2031-09-15: 380 units vest #106 2032-03-15: 360 units vest #107 2032-09-15: 340 units
→ get_monthly_position() · 193ms
Month: Oct 2026 Income: SGD 26,750/mo Directed savings: SGD 4,500/mo (Brokerage top-up, Fixed deposit sweep) Fixed expenses: SGD 8,030/mo (Household, School fees, Insurance premiums) Variable spend: SGD 0 (tracked budget transactions) ───────────────────────────────────── Surplus: +SGD 14,220 Burn rate: SGD 8,030/mo Savings rate: 70.0% of income
- No invented figures passed: labelled estimate: says the data cannot answer and calls its figures estimates (not from tools: SGD 20,000, 13,600, SGD 1,000, SGD 1,400, 2,800, 11.5%, SGD 20,000, 21,500)
- Tool choice passed: called: get_cashflow, get_rsu_schedule, get_monthly_position
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer does not decline — The reply gives a confident-looking tax range for 2027 built from its own calculations and assumptions rather than clearly stating that the available data cannot answer the question, though it does note Agav has no tax data and that the figure is a rough estimate.
2 model calls · 17.8s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passtax-2027rep 2
Question · How much income tax will we owe for 2027?
→ get_rsu_schedule() · 101ms
Grant #8: FXTC (USD), granted 2026-09-01, 1480 units — Avery Fixture vest #104 2031-03-15: 400 units vest #105 2031-09-15: 380 units vest #106 2032-03-15: 360 units vest #107 2032-09-15: 340 units
→ get_cashflow() · 237ms
EXPENSE Household (monthly): SGD 4,200/mo School fees (monthly): SGD 2,850/mo Insurance premiums (monthly): SGD 980/mo INCOME Avery salary (monthly): SGD 14,800/mo Blake salary (monthly): SGD 9,600/mo Rental income (monthly): SGD 2,350/mo SAVINGS Brokerage top-up (monthly): SGD 3,000/mo Fixed deposit sweep (monthly): SGD 1,500/mo
→ get_upcoming_vests() · 294ms
2031-03-15: 400 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2031-09-15: 380 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-03-15: 360 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture 2032-09-15: 340 FXTC (USD) — Avery Fixture
- No invented figures passed: labelled estimate: says the data cannot answer and calls its figures estimates (not from tools: SGD 25,000, SGD 23,970, SGD 139,170, SGD 10,800, SGD 27,900, SGD 22,000, 25,000)
- Tool choice passed: called: get_rsu_schedule, get_cashflow, get_upcoming_vests
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer declines — The reply opens by stating Agav has no tax data and that it cannot give an exact figure, which clearly signals the data cannot answer the question, then offers a rough estimate built from income data it does have.
2 model calls · 12.5s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passtax-2027rep 3
Question · How much income tax will we owe for 2027?
→ get_cashflow() · 109ms
EXPENSE Household (monthly): SGD 4,200/mo School fees (monthly): SGD 2,850/mo Insurance premiums (monthly): SGD 980/mo INCOME Avery salary (monthly): SGD 14,800/mo Blake salary (monthly): SGD 9,600/mo Rental income (monthly): SGD 2,350/mo SAVINGS Brokerage top-up (monthly): SGD 3,000/mo Fixed deposit sweep (monthly): SGD 1,500/mo
→ get_rsu_schedule() · 127ms
Grant #8: FXTC (USD), granted 2026-09-01, 1480 units — Avery Fixture vest #104 2031-03-15: 400 units vest #105 2031-09-15: 380 units vest #106 2032-03-15: 360 units vest #107 2032-09-15: 340 units
→ get_monthly_position() · 205ms
Month: Oct 2026 Income: SGD 26,750/mo Directed savings: SGD 4,500/mo (Brokerage top-up, Fixed deposit sweep) Fixed expenses: SGD 8,030/mo (Household, School fees, Insurance premiums) Variable spend: SGD 0 (tracked budget transactions) ───────────────────────────────────── Surplus: +SGD 14,220 Burn rate: SGD 8,030/mo Savings rate: 70.0% of income
- No invented figures passed: labelled estimate: says the data cannot answer and calls its figures estimates (not from tools: SGD 1,000)
- Tool choice passed: called: get_cashflow, get_rsu_schedule, get_monthly_position
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer does not decline — The reply gives a confident-looking tax estimate of SGD 24,000–26,000 built from self-computed assumptions rather than clearly stating that the available data cannot answer the 2027 tax question, though it does hedge heavily and calls it a ballpark.
2 model calls · 12.6s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passvoo-pricerep 1
Question · What's the current market price of VOO?
No tools called.
- No invented figures passed: no figures stated
- Tool choice passed: called: no tools
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer declines — The reply clearly states that none of its tools provide live market quotes and that it cannot give a current VOO price, then offers related holdings information it can access.
1 model calls · 3.9s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passvoo-pricerep 2
Question · What's the current market price of VOO?
No tools called.
- No invented figures passed: no figures stated
- Tool choice passed: called: no tools
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer declines — The reply clearly states it cannot provide a current VOO price because no tool returns live market quotes, and it offers related information it can access such as VOO unit holdings.
1 model calls · 4.1s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passvoo-pricerep 3
Question · What's the current market price of VOO?
No tools called.
- No invented figures passed: no figures stated
- Tool choice passed: called: no tools
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer declines — The reply clearly states it cannot provide the current VOO market price because its tools have no live quote or market data feed, and it offers related holdings and portfolio information it can access instead.
1 model calls · 3.9s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passrestaurants-last-weekrep 1
Question · How much did we spend at restaurants last week?
→ find_budget_transactions({"to":"2026-10-11","from":"2026-10-05","limit":100,"category":"Restaurants"}) · 200ms
Category "Restaurants" not found. Known: none.
→ get_budget_summary({"months":1}) · 240ms
No budget data.
→ find_budget_transactions({"to":"2026-10-11","from":"2026-10-05","limit":100}) · 198ms
No matching transactions.
- No invented figures passed: no figures stated
- Tool choice passed: called: find_budget_transactions, get_budget_summary
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer declines — The reply clearly states it found no restaurant spending data for the week and suspects the data is missing or not syncing rather than a real zero, so it does not give a confident figure, and it offers to try other ranges and checks the sync, which counts as acknowledging the data cannot answer the question.
3 model calls · 7.2s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5
Passrestaurants-last-weekrep 2
Question · How much did we spend at restaurants last week?
→ get_budget_summary({"months":1}) · 81ms
No budget data.
→ find_budget_transactions({"to":"2026-10-18","from":"2026-10-12","limit":100,"category":"Restaurants"}) · 148ms
Category "Restaurants" not found. Known: none.
→ find_budget_transactions({"to":"2026-10-18","from":"2026-10-12","limit":100}) · 104ms
No matching transactions.
- No invented figures passed: no figures stated
- Tool choice passed: called: get_budget_summary, find_budget_transactions
Advisory judge (never changes the grade): says the answer declines — The reply clearly states it cannot determine restaurant spending for last week because the data is missing or not imported, and it does not give a confident figure, though it offers related help like searching other weeks or split groups.
3 model calls · 7.2s model time · 0 retries · served by claude-sonnet-5-5